The tobacco budworm, Helicoverpa armigera, is a devastating pest of tobacco in Malawi. Experience has shown that by the time this pest is noticed, considerable damage has already been done to tobacco during the early stages of infestation. There is a need to manage future infestations correctly by combining safe and effective measures that can provide early control and detection of the pest. In recent years, the number of conventional pesticides for budworm control on tobacco has declined, and their use has increasingly become undesirable due to the buildup of resistance, concerns with pesticide residues, and environmental pollution. This has created an urgent need to diversify strategies to manage pests sustainably. One effort in this direction has been to evaluate effective and safer alternative insecticides that are compatible with integrated pest management (IPM). Experiments were conducted from 2011 to 2014 to evaluate the efficacy of 2 new insecticides, Prevathon® 5 SC, and Cyazypry 20 SC, with the aim of finding effective and safer alternatives for control of the tobacco budworm. A total of 10 treatments were evaluated in randomized complete blocks and levels of budworm infestation were evaluated in each treatment at 2, 4, and 6 wk after planting. The results indicated that Prevathon® 5 SC applied at transplanting (40 ml/10 L, 30 ml/plant) followed by a spray (14 ml/10 L water) at 4 weeks after transplanting provided effective budworm control (2.5% infestation) compared to about 20.9% infestation in untreated checks at Mwimba and 5.2% vs. 48.7% at Kandiya Research Station, respectively. Cyazypyr 20 SC applied at transplanting (10 ml/10 L, 30 ml/plant) followed by a spray (3.4 ml/10 L water) at 4 weeks after transplanting provided effective budworm control: 5.6% against 20.9% at Mwimba and 8.2% against 48.7% in the untreated at Kandiya Research Station, respectively. Prevathon® 5 SC and Cyazypyr 20 SC are promising alternatives for budworm control because they will provide the needed early insect pest protection compared with the currently recommended insecticides which are applied after pest damage is noticed.